Monday, July 7, 2008
The Glorious Judge Candidate Must Reform The Supreme Court
They get several critic question from commisioneries whose concerned about track record as judge, handle takes case, wealth asset ownership, mission and vision if they become glorious of judge.
Sudarto Radyosuwiryo, The Chairman of Administration Justice (PTUN) at
“Did your child became judge followed a test. Where? Your boys from economic degree, but why he can get job at justice court?” ask Zainal Arifin a member The Judicial Commission.
Sudarto claims, her boys has work at jurisdiction institute passed test at Jurisdictional Department and Humanity, and The Supreme of Court.
According to her, he child didn’t get success when followed test used by economic degree sertificate
“But, he accept when used junior high school sertificate, and then he continued at law major in law faculty, adjusting brevet until faction fitting,” he admits.
Zainal alsio clarification social report whose sent information if Sudarto have wealth asset like land at
”That is not true. When I stay at
Then, I get one lot. I was for twice pay at 1997.
But, we also required fund and I can’t feel equal kept up. I ask my friends, please kept on. I can’t pay again,” said Sudarto whose also former as the Chairman of Jakarta Administration Justice at 1999.
”But, society has report if you have a lot of house at
Sidarto claims, he only have one house larger about 210 meters. ”But, I have been report at 2001 and 2008. I just only have one house, sir,” answer him.
Zainal also guestion to him, “Do you still get money from governor after 37 year become judge?”
Sudarto said, he didn’t get money from gobernor again.
Mahdi Soroinda, other candidate also got questions about wealth asset at Kalibata,
”At Kalibata, how much you have car and driver. If your goes to
”Five cars,” answer Mahdi. Commissioner also question Mahdi track record, capacity and quality as judge.
To Rosmala Sitorus, others candidate, Zainal asked about morality and integrity. ”What bribes that accepted judge available economic motive?” ask him.
”To me, my children learned at country school not forces to us,” she answer to keep self. Then, Zainal asked him about ownership 40 hectare oil palm.
”I don’t have 40 pack hectares, But 16 hectare that bought at 1992, at price 5 million,” answer Rosmala.
”But from our reported, your oil palm land about 40 hectares. Oil palm prince now more expensive. I think you more richer now,” said Zainal.
”But I has rent out to others. About Rp30 million per year I get salary from oil palm production,” reply Rosmala.
Wealths asset, morality, and integrity, became materi when the candidate followed test interview.
Lalu Mariyun, other candidate proposed more serious.
”The Supreme Court have been check if you have accused to add judge ceremony by changes verdict,” ask The Vice Chairman of Judicial Commission Thahir Saimima.
Mariyun declares, ”I never do that,” he explicit.
But, Mariyun claims, if he really had checked by The State Court order by the Supreme Court. ”But, I never change or falsify verdict. I am not troublesome. And I never get penalization action,” he said.
Mariyun also claim no one matter get free when he decreed corruption case.
But, Thahir questions about free decision when handle Bank Mandiri corruption case, E.C. W Neole that issued by PN south
Commissioners didn’t forget to dig up all candidate to know about mission and vision.
Commissioners also asked about Sidarto's assumption when he article at one media if 90 percent of
”What is your argumentation for reform the supreme court agenda?” ask The Chariman of Judical Commision Busyro Muqoddas to Sidarto.
He answers, The Supreme Court must make more quality organisational formation and administration, budget, and view reform judges.
Sidarto assesses, judges which sits in The Supreme Court integrity and capability really troublesome.
Busyro also question about plaint problem to 31 glorious judges candidate goes to MA that glorious judge may not keep company the Judical Commission. ”How you assess?” ask him.
”We are shy a propose the plaint than its behalf that mutually brace connected with responsible position,” answer him.
While Mariyun kepts faith will try to fight arrears takes proceedings that is at The Supreme of Court who is still a lot of outstanding.
Monday (7 / 7) later, Judical Commission will decide maximal 18 candidate to report The Commission III Indonesia Parliement, on Wednesday (9/7).
Judical Commission will announced to public on Thursday (10 / 7).
“Pertinent determination (candidate, red) reasonably or not been nominated as candidate of glorious judge will be determined deep plenary meeting Monday following.
The glorious of judge now can't reform The Supreme Court.
Whereas, that instutition who becomes last fortress for scavenging justice often deviation handles fee of lawsuit, and is not maximal extirpate jurisdiction mafia.
“The Supreme Court reform must to do. The glorious of judge shall can reform, particularly intern consolidation , ” said Suripto, The Vice of Chariman Commission III Indonesia Parliement.
"We will to more selective," said Suripto. He added, Parliement will evaluate moral and capacity each candidate has been graduate selection process at Judicial Commission.”
In fit and proper test, he continued, parliement will also study more indept about track record and judge experience when they handle case.
He said, bad track record information gotten by parliement will be script will be dug up while fit and proper test.
”Its mean if their available have bad track record can become note for parliment. They experience handle case will be one parliement object. The Parliment will also study about the glorius judge target that shall be solve.
”We will see, what is the glorious judge while handle case shall can accomplish prescribed target. And the, one of essential about mentality and good morality ,” said politician from justice Party Fraction sejahtera (FPKS) that.
Politic contract
The Indonesian Society Jurisdiction Control (Mappi) assess positive test prosess by Judicial Commission.
But while see selection process, question format unchanged. Eventually, that must being changed, even the quality some candidate stills hesitated.
In consequence, The Chairman of Mappi Hasril Hertanto assesses, needed politics contract among parliement, judicial commission and candidates glorious judge.
Indonesia Parliament shall press glorious judge candidate to make ready checked by judicial commission if know indication mafia in jurisdiction.
"Need politics contract. When they involved jurisdiction criminal, glorious judge member shall ready checked by judicial commission, " he explicit.
According to Hasril, glorious judge a new one following shall no longer get effort to block KY's check in consideration takes shelter at turns back insitusi MA.'s force "All this time, glorious judge do ever equivocate with Konsitusi's Lawcourt decision (MK) one that decides they are not KY's probing object."
Hasril also question an interview selection mechanism by The Judicial Commission last week. He said, the material question isn’t quality, doctrinaire and normative.
He also rue closed clarification about asset wealth to each candidate.
He assesses, should be append for Judicial Commission if wealth reporting found candidate its more smaller than information report by each candidate.
"That can assess if they integrity and sincerity questionable. That becomes essential point to choice glarious judge."
Hasril also questions if commissioners didn’t maximal to interview more indept about candidates strategy to fight the criminal of jurisdiction.
M. Yamin Panca Setia
Photo: Tempo
Subscribe to Posts [Atom]
